Breville Barista Express BES870XL vs Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49

The verdict

Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 is the better buy on our scoring, 6.9 to Breville Barista Express BES870XL's 6.4. It leads on build quality & durability and maintenance & cleaning.

Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 costs $193.99 less.

Who each one suits

Breville Barista Express BES870XL

Somebody buying their first proper espresso setup who wants the grinder in the same box

Scores higher on shot quality & extraction, ease of use & learning curve.

Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49

Anyone who wants commercial fittings at home and expects to keep the machine for a decade

Scores higher on build quality & durability, maintenance & cleaning, workflow & ergonomics.

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightBreville Barista Express BES870XLGaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49
Shot Quality & Extraction22%8.56.5
Build Quality & Durability16%7.67.8
Steam Power & Milk Texturing16%6.06.0
Maintenance & Cleaning12%5.09.2
Workflow & Ergonomics12%5.06.2
Ease of Use & Learning Curve12%4.74.0
Value for Money10%6.59.2

What each one costs

Price$692.99$499.00

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Breville Barista Express BES870XLGaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49
Price$692.99$499.00
Best forSomebody buying their first proper espresso setup who wants the grinder in the same boxAnyone who wants commercial fittings at home and expects to keep the machine for a decade
What sets it apartAn integrated conical burr grinder and PID temperature control in one machine, so the grind and the shot are tuned togetherA 58mm commercial portafilter and a three way solenoid valve in a steel body made in Italy
Automatic milk frother✕—
Body MaterialStainless steelSolid steel housing with brass, Stainless steel
Boiler—1
Boiler Type—Single uncoated aluminium boiler
Built in Grinder✓✕
Made in—Italy
Machine TypeSemi-automatic espresso machine with an integrated conical burr grinderSemi-automatic espresso machine
PID control✓—
Portafilter Size—58 mm
Power1600 W1200 W
Pre Infusion✓—
Pump pressure—9 bar
Steam Wand TypeManual steam wand for hand-textured microfoamCommercial steam wand
Warranty1 year—
Water Tank—2.1 L
Weight10.0 kg9.1 kg

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Breville Barista Express BES870XL
  • +An integrated conical burr grinder that doses on demand, so beans go from hopper to basket in one action
  • +PID temperature regulation and low pressure pre-infusion
  • +Stainless steel with a 1600W element, and a one-year warranty
  • +$692.99 for a grinder and machine together, just under the $699.99 category median
  • −A manual steam wand: milk is textured by hand
  • −One year of cover, where the Barista Pro and Touch publish two
  • −10kg, the heaviest machine in this category
Full Breville Barista Express BES870XL review →
Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49
  • +A 58mm commercial portafilter, the same size professional machines use, so every accessory fits
  • +9 bar published as the actual extraction pressure rather than a pump maximum
  • +Solid steel housing with brass and stainless steel, made in Italy, with a 2.1 litre tank
  • −No built-in grinder
  • −A single uncoated aluminium boiler, which is the part that most needs descaling
  • −1200W, and no warranty term is published
Full Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 review →

Every specification, side by side

Breville Barista Express BES870XLGaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49
Price
Price$692.99$499.00
Who it suits
Best forSomebody buying their first proper espresso setup who wants the grinder in the same boxAnyone who wants commercial fittings at home and expects to keep the machine for a decade
What sets it apartAn integrated conical burr grinder and PID temperature control in one machine, so the grind and the shot are tuned togetherA 58mm commercial portafilter and a three way solenoid valve in a steel body made in Italy
Specifications
Automatic milk frother✕—
Body MaterialStainless steelSolid steel housing with brass, Stainless steel
Boiler—1
Boiler Type—Single uncoated aluminium boiler
Built in Grinder✓✕
Made in—Italy
Machine TypeSemi-automatic espresso machine with an integrated conical burr grinderSemi-automatic espresso machine
PID control✓—
Portafilter Size—58 mm
Power1600 W1200 W
Pre Infusion✓—
Pump pressure—9 bar
Ships toUSUS
Ships to NoteConfirmed on Amazon US, which is where this link points. Availability in other Amazon stores has not been checked, and a regional store may substitute a different product.Confirmed on Amazon US, which is where this link points. Availability in other Amazon stores has not been checked, and a regional store may substitute a different product.
Steam Wand TypeManual steam wand for hand-textured microfoamCommercial steam wand
Warranty1 year—
Water Tank—2.1 L
Weight10.0 kg9.1 kg

Breville Barista Express BES870XL vs Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49: common questions

Which is better, Breville Barista Express BES870XL or Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49?

Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 scores 6.9 against 6.4, both computed from published specifications rather than opinion. Breville Barista Express BES870XL is still ahead on shot quality & extraction.

Is Breville Barista Express BES870XL or Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 cheaper?

Breville Barista Express BES870XL starts at $692.99, and Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 at $499.00.

Who is Breville Barista Express BES870XL for?

Somebody buying their first proper espresso setup who wants the grinder in the same box

Who is Gaggia Classic Evo Pro RI9380/49 for?

Anyone who wants commercial fittings at home and expects to keep the machine for a decade

Keep comparing