Features

Pod machines that take third-party capsules

Machines that accept capsules from companies other than the machine's maker. It decides how much competition there is for your money after you have bought the machine, and how easily you can buy a pod at 8pm.

16 products

The best pod machines that take third-party capsules, ranked

scored on what the maker publishesOpen a row for the score working
  1. 1NespressoLattissima OneFrom $1297.7

    How it scored

    Drink Quality9.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed8.5
    Build Quality & Reliability6.0
    Maintenance & Cleaningweakest link5.0
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Machine Value for Money9.1
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$129
    Score7.7
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (2 Minutes)
    Read the Nespresso Lattissima One review →
  2. 2NespressoGran LattissimaFrom $4797.1

    How it scored

    Drink Quality9.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed8.5
    Build Quality & Reliability6.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Moneyweakest link2.4
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$479
    Score7.1
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (9 Minutes)
    Read the Nespresso Gran Lattissima review →
  3. 3NespressoCreatista PlusFrom $269.956.9

    How it scored

    Drink Quality8.0
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed7.0
    Build Quality & Reliability6.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Moneyweakest link4.1
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$269.95
    Score6.9
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (9 Minutes)
    Read the Nespresso Creatista Plus review →
  4. 4NespressoCitizFrom $349.996.3

    How it scored

    Drink Quality6.7
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice7.0
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed7.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.5
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Moneyweakest link2.9
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$349.99
    Score6.3
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offAutomatic power off after 9 minutes; setting can be changed to 30 minutes
    Read the Nespresso Citiz review →
  5. 5KeurigK-Express Single-ServeFrom $69.996.2

    How it scored

    Drink Quality4.7
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice10.0
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.2
    Build Quality & Reliability4.5
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Money10.0
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    Price from$69.99
    Score6.2
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (5 Minutes)
    Read the Keurig K-Express Single-Serve review →
  6. 6NespressoInissiaFrom $1896.2

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed5.5
    Build Quality & Reliabilityweakest link4.5
    carries 12 of the 95.5 points scored
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Money5.2
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$189
    Score6.2
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (9 Minutes)
    Read the Nespresso Inissia review →
  7. 7NespressoPixieFrom $1496.2

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice7.0
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.5
    Build Quality & Reliability5.5
    Maintenance & Cleaningweakest link3.8
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Machine Value for Money6.4
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$149
    Score6.2
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes, after 9 minutes of non-use; adjustable to 30 minutes
    Read the Nespresso Pixie review →
  8. 8KeurigK-Mini Single Serve Coffee MakerFrom $716.1

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed7.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning4.4
    Machine Value for Money10.0
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    Price from$71
    Score6.1
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes
    Read the Keurig K-Mini Single Serve Coffee Maker review →
  9. 9KeurigK-ClassicFrom $99.995.9

    How it scored

    Drink Quality4.0
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice10.0
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed5.5
    Build Quality & Reliability4.5
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.0
    Machine Value for Money8.7
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    Price from$99.99
    Score5.9
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offYes (2-Hour Auto Shutoff)
    Read the Keurig K-Classic review →
  10. 10NespressoEssenza Mini Espresso Machine by BrevilleFrom $179.955.9

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice7.0
    Running Cost Per Cup6.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.5
    Build Quality & Reliability4.5
    Maintenance & Cleaningweakest link2.5
    carries 8 of the 95.5 points scored
    Machine Value for Money5.1
    Waste & Disposal8.0
    Price from$179.95
    Score5.9
    Capsule SystemNespresso Original
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Auto shut-offAuto-off after 9 mins.
    Read the Nespresso Essenza Mini Espresso Machine by Breville review →
  11. 11CuisinartSS-10P1 Single Serve Coffee Maker5.8

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning6.9
    Machine Value for Money5.0
    no price published
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    PricePricing N/A
    Score5.8
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Cuisinart SS-10P1 Single Serve Coffee Maker review →
  12. 12Hamilton BeachFlexBrew Trio Coffee Maker5.8

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning6.9
    Machine Value for Money5.0
    no price published
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    PricePricing N/A
    Score5.8
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Trio Coffee Maker review →
  13. 13KeurigK-Elite Single Serve Coffee Maker5.8

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning6.9
    Machine Value for Money5.0
    no price published
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    PricePricing N/A
    Score5.8
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Coffee Maker review →
  14. 14FamiworthsSingle Serve Coffee Maker5.7

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice10.0
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.0
    Build Quality & Reliability4.5
    Maintenance & Cleaning3.1
    Machine Value for Money5.0
    no price published
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    PricePricing N/A
    Score5.7
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Famiworths Single Serve Coffee Maker review →
  15. 15NinjaSingle Serve Coffee Maker PB0515.7

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice8.5
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed5.0
    Build Quality & Reliability5.0
    Maintenance & Cleaning6.9
    Machine Value for Money5.0
    no price published
    Waste & Disposalweakest link3.0
    carries 10 of the 95.5 points scored
    PricePricing N/A
    Score5.7
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Ninja Single Serve Coffee Maker PB051 review →
  16. 16KeurigK-SupremeFrom $154.995.6

    How it scored

    Drink Quality5.3
    pump pressure not published
    Capsule System & Choice7.0
    Running Cost Per Cup5.5
    Ease of Use & Speed6.0
    Build Quality & Reliabilityweakest link4.5
    carries 12 of the 95.5 points scored
    Maintenance & Cleaning5.6
    Machine Value for Money5.6
    Waste & Disposal5.0
    Price from$154.99
    Score5.6
    Capsule SystemK-Cup
    Third-party CapsulesYes
    Read the Keurig K-Supreme review →
⇄ Compare
12 of 16 shown

About pod machines that take third-party capsules

Every pod machine locks you into a capsule shape. What varies is whether anyone other than the machine's maker is allowed, or able, to make that shape. That single fact governs what every cup costs for the life of the machine and how easy the capsules are to find.

Open and closed systems behave very differently

K-Cup is open enough that dozens of roasters sell compatible capsules, which is why the price per pod varies so widely and why supermarkets carry a wall of them. Nespresso Original has been widely copied and has a large compatible market. Dolce Gusto and Tassimo are far more closed, and in practice you buy from one company. An open system means competition and falling prices; a closed one means a single supplier for as long as you own the machine.

Availability matters as much as price

A closed system is also a system whose capsules are stocked where that company chooses. That is fine until you want coffee on a Sunday and the only shop nearby carries one brand of pods that is not yours. Before buying a machine, look at what is actually on the shelf in the shops you use, not at what is available online.

Compatible is not identical

Third-party capsules for a given system vary in build as well as in coffee. A shell that is slightly the wrong stiffness can pierce badly or leak, and a machine's newer generation sometimes tightens tolerances. This is not a reason to avoid them; it is a reason to buy one box before buying ten.

The related question

If your motivation is cost rather than choice, the other route is filling capsules yourself: machines that take refillable capsules is this same catalogue asked from that angle, and it saves considerably more per cup at the price of a grinder and some practice. Nespresso Original against Vertuo is worth reading before choosing a system at all, because those two are not interchangeable despite the shared name.

Frequently asked questions

Which pod systems accept third-party capsules?

K-Cup is the most open, with dozens of roasters selling compatible pods, and Nespresso Original has a large compatible market. Dolce Gusto and Tassimo are far more closed, and in practice you buy from one company.

Are third-party pods as good?

The coffee varies as much as coffee always does, and the shell matters too: a capsule of slightly the wrong stiffness can pierce badly or leak. Buy one box before committing to ten, particularly on a newer machine generation.

Does using third-party pods void the warranty?

Makers sometimes imply it. In practice a warranty covers manufacturing defects, and a fault has to be attributable to the capsule for it to matter. Check what your specific maker states rather than assuming either way.

Other features