Features

Direct trade coffee beans

Roasters who say they buy from growers directly rather than through the commodity market. It is a claim, not a certification, and what makes it worth anything is whether they publish the detail behind it.

21 products

The best direct trade coffee beans, ranked

scored on what the maker publishesOpen a row for the score working
  1. 1IntelligentsiaEl Gallo Blend$44.75/kg8.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.8
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo9.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$44.75
    Score8.5
    Box priceFrom $18.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate to Stone fruit
    Roast LevelMedium-light
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginMexico
    Read the Intelligentsia El Gallo Blend review →
  2. 2IntelligentsiaOrganic Black Cat Espresso$44.75/kg8.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.8
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo9.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$44.75
    Score8.5
    Box priceFrom $18.50
    Tasting NotesCaramel & toffee to Berry
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginEthiopia, Mexico
    Read the Intelligentsia Organic Black Cat Espresso review →
  3. 3IntelligentsiaOrganic French Roast Blend$44.75/kg8.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.8
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo9.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$44.75
    Score8.5
    Box priceFrom $18.50
    Tasting NotesCaramel & toffee to Chocolate
    Roast LevelMedium-dark
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginNicaragua
    Read the Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend review →
  4. 4IntelligentsiaOrganic Decaf House Blend$46.08/kg8.3

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.8
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.7
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$46.08
    Score8.3
    Box priceFrom $18.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate to Caramel & toffee
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginMexico
    Read the Intelligentsia Organic Decaf House Blend review →
  5. 5IntelligentsiaIllumination Blend$49.38/kg8.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.8
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.1
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$49.38
    Score8.1
    Box priceFrom $20
    Tasting NotesCitrus to Berry
    Roast LevelMedium-light
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginEthiopia, Mexico
    Read the Intelligentsia Illumination Blend review →
  6. 6IntelligentsiaBlack Cat Analog Espresso$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate to Creamy
    Roast LevelMedium-dark
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil
    Read the Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso review →
  7. 7IntelligentsiaBlack Cat Classic Espresso$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesBerry, Citrus
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil, Costa Rica
    Read the Intelligentsia Black Cat Classic Espresso review →
  8. 8IntelligentsiaEl Diablo Blend$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate, Berry
    Roast LevelMedium-dark
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginGuatemala
    Read the Intelligentsia El Diablo Blend review →
  9. 9IntelligentsiaEl Gato Blend$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate, Stone fruit
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil, Costa Rica
    Read the Intelligentsia El Gato Blend review →
  10. 10IntelligentsiaFrequency Blend$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesBerry to Chocolate
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil, El Salvador
    Read the Intelligentsia Frequency Blend review →
  11. 11IntelligentsiaHouse Blend$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesStone fruit to Caramel & toffee
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil, Honduras
    Read the Intelligentsia House Blend review →
  12. 12IntelligentsiaSublunar Espresso$42.55/kg8.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.0
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Tasting NotesCaramel & toffee, Chocolate
    Roast LevelMedium-dark
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil
    Read the Intelligentsia Sublunar Espresso review →
  13. 13IntelligentsiaDecaf Black Cat Espresso$46.08/kg7.8

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 35.7 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.1
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$46.08
    Score7.8
    Box priceFrom $18.50
    Tasting NotesChocolate, Stone fruit
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginBrazil
    Read the Intelligentsia Decaf Black Cat Espresso review →
  14. 14StumptownFounder's Blend Medium Roast7.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics7.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link5.0
    no price publishedcarries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score7.1
    Tasting NotesCreamy, Chocolate
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginCentral America, South America
    Read the Stumptown Founder's Blend Medium Roast review →
  15. 15StumptownHair Bender Medium Roast7.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics7.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link5.0
    no price publishedcarries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score7.1
    Tasting NotesCitrus, Chocolate
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginLatin America to Africa
    Read the Stumptown Hair Bender Medium Roast review →
  16. 16StumptownHomestead Blend Medium Roast7.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics7.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link5.0
    no price publishedcarries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score7.1
    Tasting NotesChocolate to Citrus
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginCentral America to East Africa
    Read the Stumptown Homestead Blend Medium Roast review →
  17. 17IntelligentsiaHonduras La Tortuga Geisha$91.27/kg6.8

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics7.1
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link4.5
    carries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$91.27
    Score6.8
    Box priceFrom $30
    Tasting NotesCitrus, Berry
    Roast LevelMedium
    Single Origin or BlendSingle origin
    OriginHonduras
    Read the Intelligentsia Honduras La Tortuga Geisha review →
  18. 18StumptownFrench Roast Dark Roast6.8

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics6.4
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link5.0
    no price publishedcarries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score6.8
    Tasting NotesSpice, Chocolate
    Roast LevelDark
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    Read the Stumptown French Roast Dark Roast review →
  19. 19IntelligentsiaSummer Solstice Blend$77.60/kg6.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    roast date printed only
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics5.7
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link4.8
    carries 14 of the 35.7 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    bag size only
    Price per kg$77.60
    Score6.5
    Box priceFrom $30
    Tasting NotesCitrus, Berry
    Roast LevelMedium-light
    Single Origin or BlendBlend
    OriginColombia to Kenya
    Read the Intelligentsia Summer Solstice Blend review →
  20. 20OriginAtlas Decaf6.3

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link5.0
    roast date printed onlycarries 20 of the 35.7 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics8.9
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo5.0
    price in GBP, not scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score6.3
    Tasting NotesStone fruit to Caramel & toffee
    Single Origin or BlendSingle origin
    OriginColombia
    Read the Origin Atlas Decaf review →
  21. 21OriginChilamate 15 Year Mierisch Anniversary6.3

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link5.0
    roast date printed onlycarries 20 of the 35.7 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics8.9
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo5.0
    price in GBP, not scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    bag size only
    PricePricing N/A
    Score6.3
    Tasting NotesStone fruit to Chocolate
    Single Origin or BlendSingle origin
    OriginNicaragua
    Read the Origin Chilamate 15 Year Mierisch Anniversary review →
⇄ Compare
12 of 21 shown

About direct trade coffee beans

Direct trade means a roaster says it buys green coffee straight from the farm, cooperative or exporter, rather than through the commodity market. Where it is real it usually means a better price to the grower and a better coffee in the bag. Where it is not, it means nothing at all, because no organisation defines the term and nobody audits it.

Nobody certifies this, which is the whole point to understand

Fairtrade, Rainforest Alliance and organic are certifications: there is a standard, an auditor and a logo somebody paid for. Direct trade is a description a roaster applies to itself. That is not automatically worse. Several of the best roasters avoid certification because the fee is a cost the farm ends up carrying, and they pay above the certified minimum anyway. But it does mean the words alone are worth nothing. What each certification label actually guarantees covers the other side.

What a real relationship looks like on the bag

The tell is specificity. A roaster with a genuine relationship can name the farm or the cooperative, the region, the altitude, the varietal and the processing method, and often the year they started buying there. A roaster using the phrase as decoration names a country and stops. Every one of those details is checkable, which is why the vague version stays vague.

Price is evidence, not proof

Direct trade coffee costs more than commodity coffee and should. But a high price is not evidence of anything on its own, and the useful question is what the roaster publishes about where it went. Some publish the price paid per pound. That is the strongest version of this claim anyone makes, and it is rare enough to be worth seeking out.

Who should care

Anyone buying at the medium-light end and paying specialty prices, because the sourcing and the cup quality travel together: a roaster who can get the same lot next year is a roaster whose coffee you can learn. If your coffee goes into milk every morning, the money is better spent elsewhere.

Frequently asked questions

Is direct trade better than Fairtrade?

They are different kinds of claim. Fairtrade is certified against a standard with an auditor and a minimum price. Direct trade is a roaster describing its own buying and is not audited by anyone. A good direct trade relationship often pays more than the Fairtrade minimum; a bad one is just words.

How do I know if a direct trade claim is real?

Look for specificity. A genuine relationship can name the farm or cooperative, the region, the altitude, the varietal and the process, and sometimes the price paid. A marketing line names a country and stops.

Does direct trade mean better coffee?

Often, but not because of the label. Roasters who buy directly tend to be buying selectively and paying for quality, and they can go back to the same lot next year. The correlation is real; the guarantee is not.

Other features