Tasting notes

Coffee with creamy and vanilla notes

Vanilla, butter and a texture rather than a taste. Roasters print it to describe mouthfeel as much as flavour, so expect a coffee that coats rather than one that tastes sweet.

39 products

The best coffee with creamy and vanilla notes, ranked

ranked by the average score of each roaster's coffeesOpen a row for details
  1. 1Fresh Roasted CoffeeOrganic Bali Blue Moon$30.86/kg8.9

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.4
    varietals not published; altitude not scoredcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo10.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
    Price per kg$30.86
    Score8.9
    Box priceFrom $17.99
    Read the Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon review →
  2. 2Fresh Roasted CoffeeOrganic Sumatra Water-Processed Decaf$33.06/kg8.9

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link6.4
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo10.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
  3. 3United StatesFresh Roasted Coffee8.8
    Coffees reviewed11
    Average score8.8
    Price per kilofrom $24.25
    Read the Fresh Roasted Coffee review →
  4. 4Fresh Roasted CoffeeIndian Monsoon Malabar$26.45/kg8.7

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.4
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo10.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
    Price per kg$26.45
    Score8.7
    Box priceFrom $14.99
    Read the Fresh Roasted Coffee Indian Monsoon Malabar review →
  5. 5IntelligentsiaBlack Cat Analog Espresso$42.55/kg8.4

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency10.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link5.7
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo8.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$42.55
    Score8.4
    Box priceFrom $17.50
    Read the Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso review →
  6. 6IntelligentsiaInstant Espresso Black Cat Classic$2.60/cup8.2

    How it scored

    Process & Cup Quality10.0
    Convenience & Format7.5
    Sourcing Transparencyweakest link2.7
    roaster or process partner named and direct trade not scoredcarries 18 of the 69.5 points scored
    Packaging & Shelf Life10.0
    resealable not scored
  7. 7United KingdomOrigin Coffee7.6
    Coffees reviewed9
    Average score7.6
    Read the Origin Coffee review →
  8. 8Death WishBlueberry CoffeeFrom $19.997.3

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link5.0
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics6.8
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo10.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
  9. 9Cooper's CaskBarrel Aged Box Set 48oz$73.45/kg7.1

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range8.7
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately6.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$73.45
    Score7.1
    Box priceFrom $99.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Barrel Aged Box Set 48oz review →
  10. 10NescafeGold Latte Instant Coffee Sachets7.0

    How it scored

    Process & Cup Quality6.0
    Convenience & Format8.0
    Sourcing Transparencyweakest link5.0
    roaster or process partner named and direct trade not publishedcarries 18 of the 69.5 points scored
    Packaging & Shelf Life10.0
    resealable not published
  11. 11United StatesStumptown Coffee Roasters6.9
    Coffees reviewed4
    Average score6.9
    Read the Stumptown Coffee Roasters review →
  12. 12StumptownFounder's Blend Medium Roast6.9

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency7.9
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics7.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link5.0
    no price publishedcarries 14 of the 45.8 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
  13. 13Cooper's CaskBarrel Aged Box Set$88.07/kg6.5

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range9.0
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately4.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$88.07
    Score6.5
    Box priceFrom $39.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Barrel Aged Box Set review →
  14. 14Black RifleComplete Mission Fuel Kit$44.94/kg6.3

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range8.5
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately7.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness5.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$44.94
    Score6.3
    Box priceFrom $61.16
    Read the Black Rifle Complete Mission Fuel Kit review →
  15. 15Cooper's CaskCold Brew Box Set$58.72/kg6.1

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range7.0
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately5.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$58.72
    Score6.1
    Box priceFrom $39.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Cold Brew Box Set review →
  16. 16Cooper's CaskEspresso Box Set$58.72/kg6.1

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range7.0
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately5.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$58.72
    Score6.1
    Box priceFrom $39.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Espresso Box Set review →
  17. 17Kicking HorseHappy Camper Medium Roast5.7

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link5.0
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics6.4
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo5.0
    no price published
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
  18. 18Koa CoffeePrivate Reserve Medium Roast$170.86/kg5.6

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency7.9
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics6.8
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link1.9
    carries 14 of the 45.8 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$170.86
    Score5.6
    Box priceFrom $42
    Read the Koa Coffee Private Reserve Medium Roast review →
  19. 19Cooper's CaskBarrel Aged Box Set with Mug$138.01/kg5.5

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range7.0
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately3.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$138.01
    Score5.5
    Box priceFrom $46.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Barrel Aged Box Set with Mug review →
  20. 20Cooper's CaskWine Barrel Aged Box Set$102.74/kg5.5

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range7.0
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately3.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness10.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$102.74
    Score5.5
    Box priceFrom $34.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Wine Barrel Aged Box Set review →
  21. 21United StatesKoa Coffee5.5
    Coffees reviewed8
    Average score5.5
    Price per kilofrom $170.86
    Read the Koa Coffee review →
  22. 22Dolly Parton's Cup of AmbitionLight Roast$38.18/kg5.3

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency5.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link3.6
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo6.0
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not scored
    Price per kg$38.18
    Score5.3
    Box priceFrom $12.99
    Read the Dolly Parton's Cup of Ambition Light Roast review →
  23. 23Black RifleFall Flavored Coffee Bundle$53.20/kg5.2

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range5.5
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately7.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness5.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$53.20
    Score5.2
    Box priceFrom $51.27
    Read the Black Rifle Fall Flavored Coffee Bundle review →
  24. 24Black RifleMedium Roast Bundle$44.94/kg5.2

    How it scored

    Variety & How Well It Introduces the Range5.5
    Value Against Buying the Bags Separately7.0
    Presentation & Gift Readiness5.0
    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link0.0
    ships after roast not publishedcarries 14 of the 71.2 points scored
    Price per kg$44.94
    Score5.2
    Box priceFrom $45.87
    Read the Black Rifle Medium Roast Bundle review →
  25. 25LavazzaSuper Crema5.2

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link5.0
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics5.4
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo5.0
    no price published
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    packaging not published
  26. 26United StatesLion Vanilla Macadamia Nut Coffee$46.96/kg5.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency5.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link3.6
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo4.9
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$46.96
    Score5.0
    Box priceFrom $13.95
    Read the Lion Vanilla Macadamia Nut Coffee review →
  27. 27Royal KonaVanilla Macadamia 10% Kona Blend$46.69/kg4.6

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency5.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethicsweakest link3.6
    altitude and varietals not publishedcarries 16 of the 45.8 points scored
    Value Per Kilo4.6
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$46.69
    Score4.6
    Box priceFrom $13.95
    Read the Royal Kona Vanilla Macadamia 10% Kona Blend review →
  28. 28United StatesHawaii Coffee Company4.4
    Coffees reviewed4
    Average score4.4
    Price per kilofrom $46.69
    Read the Hawaii Coffee Company review →
  29. 29United StatesHawaiian Lion 24k Gold Roast 100% Kona Coffee$171.88/kg4.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparency5.0
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics5.4
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kiloweakest link1.4
    carries 14 of the 45.8 points scored
    Packaging & Freshness Retention6.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$171.88
    Score4.1
    Box priceFrom $34.95
    Read the Hawaiian Lion 24k Gold Roast 100% Kona Coffee review →
  30. 30United StatesCooper’s Cask Coffee3.9
    Coffees reviewed22
    Average score3.9
    Price per kilofrom $33.05
    Read the Cooper’s Cask Coffee review →
  31. 31Black RifleJust Black Roast$35.27/kg3.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics2.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo4.1
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$35.27
    Score3.5
    Box priceFrom $16.99
    Read the Black Rifle Just Black Roast review →
  32. 32Cooper's CaskMalt Whiskey Barrel Aged$61.71/kg3.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics4.3
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$61.71
    Score3.5
    Box priceFrom $29.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Malt Whiskey Barrel Aged review →
  33. 33Cooper's CaskPinot Noir Barrel Aged$61.71/kg3.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics4.3
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$61.71
    Score3.5
    Box priceFrom $29.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Pinot Noir Barrel Aged review →
  34. 34Cooper's CaskRum Barrel Aged$61.71/kg3.5

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics4.3
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.8
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$61.71
    Score3.5
    Box priceFrom $29.95
    Read the Cooper's Cask Rum Barrel Aged review →
  35. 35United StatesBlack Rifle Coffee3.2
    Coffees reviewed17
    Average score3.2
    Price per kilofrom $35.27
    Read the Black Rifle Coffee review →
  36. 36United StatesBlack Rifle Coffee or Die Roast$49.94/kg3.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics2.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.9
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$49.94
    Score3.1
    Box priceFrom $16.99
    Read the Black Rifle Coffee or Die Roast review →
  37. 37Black RifleFreedom Roast$49.94/kg3.1

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics2.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.9
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$49.94
    Score3.1
    Box priceFrom $16.99
    Read the Black Rifle Freedom Roast review →
  38. 38Black RifleBourbon Roast$57.70/kg3.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics2.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.5
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$57.70
    Score3.0
    Box priceFrom $17.99
    Read the Black Rifle Bourbon Roast review →
  39. 39Black RifleFool's Gold Irish Cream$52.88/kg3.0

    How it scored

    Freshness & Roast Date Transparencyweakest link2.1
    carries 20 of the 45.8 points scored
    Sourcing Transparency & Ethics2.5
    altitude and varietals not published
    Value Per Kilo2.7
    Packaging & Freshness Retention8.0
    packaging not published
    Price per kg$52.88
    Score3.0
    Box priceFrom $17.99
    Read the Black Rifle Fool's Gold Irish Cream review →
⇄ Compare
12 of 39 shown ·

About coffee with creamy and vanilla notes

Creamy is the note roasters reach for when they are describing how a coffee feels rather than how it tastes. Vanilla, butter, cream and milk chocolate all sit here, and the common thread is weight in the mouth: a coffee that coats rather than one that is sweet.

Creamy coffee: body comes from how you brew

This is the useful part, because it is the one you control. Body comes from what makes it into the cup, and the filter decides that. A French press brewer uses a metal mesh, so oils and fine particles go through and the cup is heavy. A paper filter traps both, so pour over coffee made with the same beans is cleaner and lighter. If you want creamy, the brewer is a bigger lever than the bag. Immersion against percolation covers the mechanism.

Vanilla in coffee is nearly always added flavoring

Roasting does not produce vanilla. When a coffee is named for it, flavouring has been applied to roasted beans, and that is one of the two or three most popular flavoured coffees there is. A coffee that reads as creamy without being flavoured is describing texture and a soft, low-acid sweetness rather than an actual vanilla flavour, and it will be far more subtle.

Why creamy coffee works in a latte

Body and sweetness are what get through milk. If most of your coffee is a flat white or a cappuccino, a coffee described as creamy at a medium-dark roast will still be there at the other end, where a bright citrus-forward coffee will not. Steaming milk properly is the other half of that cup.

Why freshness matters for creamy coffee

The oils that carry body are the ones that go stale, so a creamy coffee that has sat open for a month reads flat and papery rather than merely weaker. Buy smaller bags, keep them sealed, and prefer a roaster who prints a roast date. Coffees with a printed roast date are listed separately.

Frequently asked questions about coffee with creamy and vanilla notes

Does creamy coffee contain dairy?

No. It is a description of mouthfeel: a coffee with enough body and oil to coat the tongue. Nothing is added, and it is drunk black as often as with milk.

Is vanilla coffee flavoured?

Almost certainly. Roasting does not produce vanilla, so a coffee named for it has had flavouring applied to roasted beans. A coffee that is described as creamy without being flavoured is talking about texture and soft sweetness instead.

How do I get more body in my coffee?

Change the filter before you change the bag. A French press lets oils and fines through and gives a heavy cup; paper traps both and gives a cleaner, lighter one. Grinding a little finer and using a slightly higher dose also add weight.

Other tasting notes