11 products reviewed

Coffee Roasters

Every coffee roasters we have reviewed, scored on the specifications the maker publishes.

Our pick

· research-based, chosen for a reason, not a rating
Cooper’s Cask Coffee
★ Editor’s pick
Cooper’s Cask Coffee

Coffee drinkers seeking barrel-aged and single-origin specialty beans with a unique whiskey or rum flavor influence

5.8From $39.95Read review →
Unless…
…you want it cheap

Least expensive here, at $16.99.

The best coffee roasters, ranked

scored on what the maker publishes · open a row for the working
  1. 1Cooper’s Cask Coffee5.8
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Creamy
    Price
    From $39.95
    Read review →
  2. 2Black Rifle Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Berry
    Price
    From $16.99
    Read review →
  3. 3Death Wish Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Nutty to Chocolate
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  4. 4Intelligentsia Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Caramel & toffee to Stone fruit
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  5. 5Kicking Horse Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Smoky
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  6. 6Koa Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Berry
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  7. 7Lavazza
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate, Spice
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  8. 8Origin Coffee
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  9. 9Peet's Coffee
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  10. 10Stumptown Coffee Roasters
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Malt & bread
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
  11. 11Volcanica Coffee
    Tasting notes
    Chocolate to Spice
    Price
    Pricing N/A
    Read review →
⇄ Compare

How to choose a coffee roaster

A roaster is the company that buys green coffee and roasts it, and it has more influence over what you taste than the machine you brew with. These pages collect each roaster's coffees in one place so you can see what a company actually publishes across its whole range rather than on one bag.

The roast date is the single most useful thing on a bag

Coffee is at its best from roughly three days to a month after roasting. Before three days it is still releasing carbon dioxide and brews unevenly; after a month the aromatics have faded, and by three months a bag is noticeably flat.

A best before date does not tell you this. It is typically a year out and says nothing about when the coffee was actually roasted, which could have been eleven months ago.

So a printed roast date is the clearest signal a roaster gives about how it expects its coffee to be treated. Very few large roasters print one, and the ones that do are making a claim they can be held to.

Traceability, in the order it gets more meaningful

"Beans from around the world" tells you nothing at all.

A named country is a start. A named region is better, because coffee from one part of a country tastes distinctly different from another.

A named farm, estate or cooperative is the real thing. It means the roaster knows whose coffee it bought, and it is the level at which a relationship with a producer becomes checkable rather than a phrase.

Altitude and varietal are the specifications above that. Both affect flavour directly and both are rare on a supermarket shelf.

Certifications say a different thing from direct trade

Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance and USDA Organic are audited by third parties against published standards. They are limited in what they cover, but they are verified by someone other than the seller.

Direct trade is not a certification. It is a roaster describing its own buying practice, and its value depends entirely on how specific the description is. A programme with published commitments and named producers means something. The phrase "sourcing with impact", naming no body, no programme and no commitment, means almost nothing.

Judge both by what is checkable. A certification is checkable because someone audits it. A trade relationship is checkable when the producer is named.

Reading a roaster rather than a bag

The advantage of looking at a whole range is that inconsistencies show up. A roaster that certifies most of its coffees but not one of them has made a decision worth knowing about. A roaster that publishes tasting notes on four bags and none on its flagship is telling you something about that flagship.

Buyer ratings across a range are worth the same kind of look. One low-rated bag means little; a pattern across several substantial review counts is a signal, even when the sourcing on paper looks good.

Reading on coffee roasters

What to know before you pick one.

Frequently asked

Why does the roaster matter more than the machine?

The roaster chooses the green coffee and decides how it is roasted, which sets what flavours exist in the bean before you ever touch it. Brewing can express or waste that, but it cannot add what is not there.

How fresh should coffee be?

Best from about three days to a month after roasting. Before three days it is still degassing and brews unevenly; after a month the aromatics fade, and by three months it is noticeably flat.

Is a best before date the same as a roast date?

No, and the difference matters. A best before date is typically a year out and tells you nothing about when the coffee was roasted, which could have been eleven months earlier.

Is direct trade better than Fair Trade?

They are different kinds of claim. Fair Trade is audited by a third party against a published standard. Direct trade is a roaster describing its own practice, which means a great deal when producers and commitments are named and very little when it is just a phrase.

What sourcing detail should I look for?

In increasing order of usefulness: a country, a region, a named farm or cooperative, and then altitude and varietal. A named farm is where a roaster is claiming to know whose coffee it bought.

What is the best coffee roaster?

Based on our research across the category, Cooper’s Cask Coffee is our editor's pick for coffee roaster. Coffee drinkers seeking barrel-aged and single-origin specialty beans with a unique whiskey or rum flavor influence

Is there a cheap coffee roaster worth buying?

Black Rifle Coffee is the least expensive we have reviewed in this category at $16.99. Cheapest is not the same as best value: the review says which corners were cut.

How much does a coffee roaster cost?

The ones we have reviewed run from about $16.99 to $39.95. Price tracks build material, capacity and how much of the specification the maker publishes.