Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso vs Intelligentsia Frequency Blend

The verdict

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso and Intelligentsia Frequency Blend score the same, 8.0 out of 10, so the choice is what each is better at rather than which is better.

Who each one suits

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Intelligentsia Frequency Blend

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightIntelligentsia Black Cat Analog EspressoIntelligentsia Frequency Blend
Freshness & Roast Date Transparency20%10.010.0
Sourcing Transparency & Ethics16%5.75.7
Value Per Kilo14%8.88.8
Packaging & Freshness Retention10%8.08.0

What each one costs

Price$17.50$17.50
Cost per kg
The figure that decides what the choice costs over a year, not on the day.
$42.55/kg$42.55/kg

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog EspressoIntelligentsia Frequency Blend
What sets it apartThe Brazilian-only Black Cat, roasted medium-dark, where the Classic blends two originsBrazil and El Salvador, the only Salvadoran component in the Intelligentsia range here
Brew MethodsEspressoAutomatic Drip
OriginBrazilBrazil, El Salvador
Roast LevelMedium-darkMedium
Roast ProfileTraditionalComforting
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, baking spices, toasted marshmallowGolden raisin, raw sugar, cocoa

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso
  • +Built and roasted specifically to hold up in milk, which most espresso blends only claim.
  • +More forgiving of an imperfect grind than the lighter Classic, which matters on a home machine.
  • +Direct Trade tagged, with the origin country named on the blend.
  • +Identical price to the Classic, so the choice is about the cup rather than the budget.
  • −A darker roast gives up the fruit acidity that makes the Classic interesting as a straight shot.
  • −Only two sizes, and the larger is 2.27 kg of an oily roast to keep fresh.
  • −About $42.55 a kilo, above Cooper's Cask at $33 and well above supermarket coffee.
Full Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso review →
Intelligentsia Frequency Blend
  • +The cheapest Direct Trade coffee in the range, level on price with two blends that carry no trade tag.
  • +Built as an everyday crowd pleaser, which is the right brief for a household bag.
  • +Dried fruit and sugar give it more character than a neutral house blend.
  • +Origins, roast profile, flavour profile and trade terms all published as tags.
  • −Designed to please everyone, which means it is nobody's favourite cup.
  • −No organic certification, where El Gallo and Illumination carry both that and Direct Trade.
  • −Only two sizes, and the larger is 2.27 kg to keep fresh.
Full Intelligentsia Frequency Blend review →

Every specification, side by side

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog EspressoIntelligentsia Frequency Blend
Price
Price$17.50$17.50
Who it suits
Best forpeople who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roasterpeople who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster
What sets it apartThe Brazilian-only Black Cat, roasted medium-dark, where the Classic blends two originsBrazil and El Salvador, the only Salvadoran component in the Intelligentsia range here
Specifications
Bag Sizes340 g (12 oz)340 g (12 oz)
Brew MethodsEspressoAutomatic Drip
CertificationsNone claimed by the makerNone claimed by the maker
Decaf in the range✕✕
Direct Trade✓✓
Farm or Cooperative Named✕✕
FlavouredNot flavouredNot flavoured
OriginBrazilBrazil, El Salvador
Price per kg42.55 USD42.55 USD
Roast Date Printed✓✓
Roast LevelMedium-darkMedium
Roast ProfileTraditionalComforting
Roaster CountryUnited StatesUnited States
Roaster Country CodeUSUS
Roaster NamedIntelligentsia CoffeeIntelligentsia Coffee
SeasonalYear roundYear round
Ships toUS, worldwideUS, worldwide
Ships to NoteShips internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.Ships internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.
Origin structureBlendBlend
Subscription Available✓✓
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, baking spices, toasted marshmallowGolden raisin, raw sugar, cocoa
Whole Bean or GroundWhole bean, GroundWhole bean, Ground

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso vs Intelligentsia Frequency Blend: common questions

Which is better, Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso or Intelligentsia Frequency Blend?

Both score 8.0 out of 10 on the specifications their makers publish, so neither is ahead overall. Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso leads on nothing scored.

Is Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso or Intelligentsia Frequency Blend cheaper?

Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso starts at $17.50, and Intelligentsia Frequency Blend at $17.50. Per kg they work out at $42.55/kg and $42.55/kg.

Who is Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso for?

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Who is Intelligentsia Frequency Blend for?

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Keep comparing