Intelligentsia El Gato Blend vs Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend

The verdict

Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend is the better buy on our scoring, 8.5 to Intelligentsia El Gato Blend's 8.0. It leads on sourcing transparency & ethics and value per kilo.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend costs $1 less.

Who each one suits

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Scores higher on sourcing transparency & ethics, value per kilo.

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightIntelligentsia El Gato BlendIntelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend
Freshness & Roast Date Transparency20%10.010.0
Sourcing Transparency & Ethics16%5.76.8
Value Per Kilo14%8.89.0
Packaging & Freshness Retention10%8.08.0

What each one costs

Price$17.50$18.50
Cost per kg
The figure that decides what the choice costs over a year, not on the day.
$42.55/kg$44.75/kg

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Intelligentsia El Gato BlendIntelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend
Price$17.50$18.50
What sets it apartThe same Brazil and Costa Rica pairing as Black Cat Classic, roasted for filter rather than espressoOrganic Nicaraguan beans taken to French roast, the darkest Intelligentsia sell here
CertificationsNone claimed by the makerOrganic
OriginBrazilMexico
Price per kg42.55 USD44.75 USD
Roast LevelMediumMedium-dark
Roast ProfileComfortingTraditional
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, baked apple, plumMolasses, pipe tobacco, dark chocolate

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend
  • +The flagship Black Cat profile rebuilt for filter brewing rather than sold into the wrong brewer.
  • +Level with House Blend at the entry price of the range, so the choice is flavour not budget.
  • +Comforting and chocolate-driven, which is the more forgiving of the two entry blends.
  • +Origins, roast profile and flavour profile all published as structured tags.
  • −Built for drip, so it is the wrong bag for an espresso machine despite the Black Cat association.
  • −Only two sizes, and the larger is 2.27 kg to keep fresh.
Full Intelligentsia El Gato Blend review →
Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend
  • +Organic certification and Direct Trade on a dark roast, which is rare on a specialty menu.
  • +The roast intention stated plainly as extended roasting for a semi-sweet, heavy body.
  • +Single named country of origin behind the darkest blend they sell.
  • +Only a dollar over the entry blends despite two certifications.
  • −A French roast narrows what any coffee can show, however carefully it is done.
  • −Filed for drip, so it is not the bag for an espresso machine despite the depth.
  • −Only two sizes, and the larger is 2.27 kg to keep fresh.
Full Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend review →

Every specification, side by side

Intelligentsia El Gato BlendIntelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend
Price
Price$17.50$18.50
Who it suits
Best forpeople who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roasterpeople who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster
What sets it apartThe same Brazil and Costa Rica pairing as Black Cat Classic, roasted for filter rather than espressoOrganic Nicaraguan beans taken to French roast, the darkest Intelligentsia sell here
Specifications
Bag Sizes340 g (12 oz)340 g (12 oz)
Brew MethodsAutomatic DripAutomatic Drip
CertificationsNone claimed by the makerOrganic
Decaf in the range✕✕
Direct Trade✓✓
Farm or Cooperative Named✕✕
FlavouredNot flavouredNot flavoured
OriginBrazilMexico
Price per kg42.55 USD44.75 USD
Roast Date Printed✓✓
Roast LevelMediumMedium-dark
Roast ProfileComfortingTraditional
Roaster CountryUnited StatesUnited States
Roaster Country CodeUSUS
Roaster NamedIntelligentsia CoffeeIntelligentsia Coffee
SeasonalYear roundYear round
Ships toUS, worldwideUS, worldwide
Ships to NoteShips internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.Ships internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.
Origin structureBlendBlend
Subscription Available✓✓
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, baked apple, plumMolasses, pipe tobacco, dark chocolate
Whole Bean or GroundWhole bean, GroundWhole bean, Ground

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend vs Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend: common questions

Which is better, Intelligentsia El Gato Blend or Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend?

Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend scores 8.5 against 8.0, both computed from published specifications rather than opinion.

Is Intelligentsia El Gato Blend or Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend cheaper?

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend starts at $17.50, and Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend at $18.50. Per kg they work out at $42.55/kg and $44.75/kg.

Who is Intelligentsia El Gato Blend for?

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Who is Intelligentsia Organic French Roast Blend for?

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

Keep comparing