Intelligentsia El Gato Blend Coffee Bean Review

people who want chocolate + molasses from a direct trade roaster

El Gato Blend is Intelligentsia's Black Cat profile rebuilt for filter brewing, from Brazilian and Costa Rican coffee, in 12 oz and 5 lb bags from $17.50 or about $42.55 a kilo.

Spec-led review. Built from the manufacturer’s published specification and price rather than hands-on testing. Figures we could not find stated are left blank instead of estimated. Updated when we get one in.

Where you can buy itShips worldwide

Ships internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.

everything else that ships outside the US

Our rating
8.1/ 10
Very good
4 of 6 scored, out of 35.7 points · 64.3 not judgeable from specs

How we rate coffee beans — what each criterion measures, and what we cannot.

Taste & Flavour Quality
28 pts · not scored from specs

Black Cat Classic's alter ego, built for filter rather than espresso: comforting with subtle fruit accents and tagged chocolate and molasses.

why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 28 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Freshness & Roast Date Transparency (roast date printed only)10.0 / 10
worth 8 of 35.7 · 12 unpublished · well evidenced

Two sizes and a subscription, roasted in Chicago. A 5 lb bag is 2.27 kg to keep fresh once it is opened.

how we got 10.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Roast date printedTrue4.0 / 4.0
Not best-before onlynot applicable
Ships after roastnot applicable
One-way valvenot applicable

The rows that apply here are worth 4.0 between them and this one took 4.0, which is 10.0 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 8 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

Sourcing Transparency & Ethics (altitude and varietals not published)5.7 / 10
worth 11.2 of 35.7 · 4.8 unpublished · well evidenced

Brazil and Costa Rica named on the blend, the same origin pair as the flagship espresso.

how we got 5.7

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Origin typeBlend1.0 / 1.5
Origin namedBrazil1.5 / 1.5
Altitude publishednot applicable
Varietals publishednot applicable
CertificationsNone claimed by the maker0.0 / 1.5
Direct tradeTrue1.5 / 1.5
Farm or co-op namedNo0.0 / 1.0

The rows that apply here are worth 7.0 between them and this one took 4.0, which is 5.7 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 11.2 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

Value Per Kilo8.9 / 10
worth 14 of 35.7 · well evidenced

About $42.55 a kilo in the 5 lb bag, level with House Blend at the entry price of the range.

how we got 8.9
Roast Consistency
12 pts · not scored from specs

Built to carry the Black Cat ethos into a filter brewer, which means holding a profile rather than following a lot.

why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 12 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Packaging & Freshness Retention (bag size only)8.0 / 10
worth 2.5 of 35.7 · 7.5 unpublished · well evidenced

12 oz and 5 lb, whole bean or ground. The large bag saves about seventeen percent per gram and suits a cafe more than a kitchen.

how we got 8.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Packagingnot applicable
One-way valvenot applicable
Bag size['340 g (12 oz)']2.0 / 2.5

The rows that apply here are worth 2.5 between them and this one took 2.0, which is 8.0 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 2.5 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

How Intelligentsia El Gato Blend tastes

The roaster’s own notes, in the order they list them. Roasters lead with what they want tasted first, so the bars follow that order rather than any score of ours.

  • Dark Chocolate
  • Baked Apple
  • Plum

Every way to buy it

FormatSizePricePer kiloPer cup
Whole bean or ground12 oz$17.50$51.47$0.77
Whole bean or ground5 lb$96.50$42.55best$0.64
How these prices are worked out
  • Prices are the roaster’s own, and they change.
  • Per cup for a bag is worked out at 15 g of coffee a cup, which is a stated convention rather than a measurement. Pods are exact, because the count is printed on the box.
The verdict

About $42.55 a kilo in the 5 lb bag, identical to House Blend and the entry price of the range. The 12 oz bag is $17.50 and the 5 lb is $96.50, a saving of roughly seventeen percent per gram. Because El Gato and House Blend cost exactly the same, nobody should choose between them on price. Against Cooper's Cask at about $33 a kilo this is dearer and better documented.

Pros

  • The flagship Black Cat profile rebuilt for filter brewing rather than sold into the wrong brewer.
  • Level with House Blend at the entry price of the range, so the choice is flavour not budget.
  • Comforting and chocolate-driven, which is the more forgiving of the two entry blends.
  • Origins, roast profile and flavour profile all published as structured tags.

Cons

  • Built for drip, so it is the wrong bag for an espresso machine despite the Black Cat association.
  • Only two sizes, and the larger is 2.27 kg to keep fresh.
From $17.50

What is Intelligentsia El Gato Blend?

The filter version of the flagship: the roaster calls it Black Cat Classic's alter ego, designed for drip rather than a machine.

Black Cat is an espresso blend, and an espresso blend through a filter is usually heavy and flat. El Gato exists to carry the same ethos into a drip brewer, using the same origin pair of Brazil and Costa Rica but roasted and blended for a different extraction.

It is $17.50 for 12 oz, level with House Blend at the entry price, whole bean or ground with a subscription. Tagged Comforting on roast and chocolate and molasses on flavour.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend Taste: What It Actually Tastes Like

Comforting and chocolate-driven with subtle fruit accents, which is the Black Cat profile with the volume turned down.

Where Black Cat Classic is syrupy and acidic under espresso pressure, El Gato through a filter is rounder and quieter. The chocolate carries and the fruit becomes an accent rather than the headline, which is what most people want from a daily drip coffee.

It is the more comforting of the two entry blends. House Blend is bright and fruit-forward at the same price; this is the one to buy if that reads as too sharp first thing.

How fresh is it when it arrives?

Roasted in Chicago and shipped direct, in two sizes with a subscription.

The 12 oz bag is the sensible choice for a household. A 5 lb bag opened on a counter is losing ground for weeks, and a subscription answers freshness better than bulk buying for anyone drinking a bag a fortnight.

Whole bean holds far longer than ground and costs the same, so it is the default unless there is no grinder in the house.

Where the coffee comes from

Brazil and Costa Rica named, the same pair behind the flagship espresso.

Intelligentsia publish roast profile, flavour profile, origin countries and trade terms as structured tags rather than burying them in prose, so very little on this page had to be taken on trust.

Like House Blend, this carries no Direct Trade tag, so the sourcing claim rests on the named countries. That is worth knowing given how much of the range does carry it.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend vs Intelligentsia Black Cat Analog Espresso

Against House Blend at the same price, this is chocolate where House is fruit.

House Blend is tagged apple and raw sugar and described as bright and lively. El Gato is tagged chocolate and molasses and described as comforting. Both are $17.50 for 12 oz and both are built for drip, so the decision is entirely about which cup you want.

Against Black Cat Classic at the same price, that one is an espresso blend and this is its filter counterpart. Buying Black Cat for a drip machine is the mistake El Gato exists to prevent.

If you own a filter brewer and like chocolate more than citrus, this is the bag.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend price per kilo: how it compares

About $42.55 a kilo in the 5 lb bag, identical to House Blend and the entry price of the range.

The 12 oz bag is $17.50 and the 5 lb is $96.50, a saving of roughly seventeen percent per gram. Because El Gato and House Blend cost exactly the same, nobody should choose between them on price.

Against Cooper's Cask at about $33 a kilo this is dearer and better documented. Against a supermarket specialty bag it is roughly double, and the roast profile, flavour profile and origins are all published rather than implied.

Who should buy it (and who should not)

Right for a daily drip drinker who wants the flagship profile without an espresso machine; wrong for a pour over chasing acidity.

Buy it if you brew drip or a cafetiere, want a comforting chocolate-driven cup, and like the idea of the Black Cat profile without owning the machine it was built for. It is the most forgiving everyday bag in the range.

Take House Blend instead if you want brightness and fruit at the same price. Take Black Cat Classic or Analog if you actually own an espresso machine, since El Gato is not built for one.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is El Gato Blend?

Intelligentsia describe it as Black Cat Classic's alter ego: the same ethos and the same Brazil and Costa Rica origin pair, blended and roasted for drip or filter brewing rather than for an espresso machine. It is $17.50 for 12 oz, level with House Blend.

Is El Gato the same as Black Cat?

No. Black Cat Classic is an espresso blend and El Gato is the filter counterpart. They share an origin pair and a flavour profile tag, but an espresso blend through a filter is usually heavy and flat, which is exactly the problem El Gato exists to solve.

El Gato or House Blend?

Both are $17.50 for 12 oz and both are built for drip. El Gato is tagged chocolate and molasses and described as comforting; House Blend is tagged apple and raw sugar and described as bright and lively. Chocolate or fruit, not cheaper or dearer.

Can you use El Gato for espresso?

It is built for filter and tagged for automatic drip. It will pull, but the roast and blend are aimed at a slower extraction. If you own a machine, Black Cat Analog for milk drinks or Black Cat Classic for straight shots are the ones designed for it at the same price.

Is El Gato Direct Trade?

No. It names Brazil and Costa Rica as origins but carries no Direct Trade tag, the same as House Blend. Frequency Blend at the same $17.50 does carry it, and El Gallo and Illumination carry both Direct Trade and organic certification.

How much is El Gato per cup?

At about $42.55 a kilo in the 5 lb bag and 15 grams a cup, roughly 64 cents, or nearer 77 cents from the 12 oz bag. That is the entry price across the Intelligentsia range, shared with House Blend and the two caffeinated Black Cats.

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend appears in

Intelligentsia El Gato Blend is featured in

More on coffee beans

Background reading that puts this review in context.

Alternatives to Intelligentsia El Gato Blend

See all Intelligentsia El Gato Blend alternatives →

Other Coffee Beans options we've reviewed.