Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods vs Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods

The verdict

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods and Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods score the same, 6.9 out of 10, so the choice is what each is better at rather than which is better.

Who each one suits

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods

A dark, cocoa-heavy K-Cup for somebody who wants the pod compostable and does not want it weak

Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods

Chemical-free Swiss Water decaf in a pod that composts

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightTayst Bold & Brazen Coffee PodsTayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods
What Is In The Capsule26%7.07.0
Cost Per Cup, and Per Kilo22%3.63.6
Recycling & Disposal18%9.09.0
System, Range & Availability18%9.09.0
Sourcing & Certification16%8.18.1

What each one costs

Price$41.65$41.65
Cost per pod
The figure that decides what the choice costs over a year, not on the day.
$1.04/pod$1.04/pod

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee PodsTayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods
Best forA dark, cocoa-heavy K-Cup for somebody who wants the pod compostable and does not want it weakChemical-free Swiss Water decaf in a pod that composts
Decaf in the range✓✓
Decaf Process—Swiss Water Process
Decaffeinated✕✓
Tasting NotesRich and full-bodied with a smoky cocoa finishDeep and dark, full-bodied, smooth finish

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods
  • +BPI certification covers the pod, lid, ring and mesh, not one component with the rest unsaid
  • +Rainforest Alliance Certified beans, so the sourcing claim is audited rather than described
  • +A $20 Down To Earth return kit gives you a composting route when your council has none
  • +Cheaper per cup than Nespresso's Vertuo Melozio at $1.40
  • −$1.04 a pod against $0.64 for San Francisco Bay's OneCUP, which carries the same BPI certification
  • −Commercially compostable only, in a landfill bin the certification changes nothing
  • −No bulk discount: 40, 50 and 60 pods all work out at the same $1.04
  • −No dose published, so the price per kilo cannot be calculated
  • −Origins not published for the blend
Full Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods review →
Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods
  • +Swiss Water Process named on the product, where most pod decaf does not say
  • +No decaf premium, the same $1.04 as the caffeinated blends
  • +Full body and dark roast, which decaf pods often lack
  • +Same BPI certified pod and Rainforest Alliance beans as the rest of the range
  • −Decaf K-Cups exist at roughly half the price if the method does not matter to you
  • −Commercial composting only, same as the rest of the range
  • −No dose or origins published
Full Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods review →

Every specification, side by side

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee PodsTayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods
Price
Price$41.65$41.65
Who it suits
Best forA dark, cocoa-heavy K-Cup for somebody who wants the pod compostable and does not want it weakChemical-free Swiss Water decaf in a pod that composts
Specifications
Box price41.65 USD41.65 USD
FitsK-CupK-Cup
Capsule MaterialPlant-based, BPI certified commercially compostablePlant-based, BPI certified commercially compostable
Capsule SystemK-CupK-Cup
Capsules per box4040
CertificationsBPI Certified Compostable (PurPod100), Rainforest Alliance Certified beansBPI Certified Compostable (PurPod100), Rainforest Alliance Certified beans
Cost per capsule1.041.04
Decaf in the range✓✓
Decaf Process—Swiss Water Process
FlavouredNot flavouredNot flavoured
Decaffeinated✕✓
Take-back schemeCommercial composting only, not home compostable; Tayst sell a $20 Down To Earth return kit for posting used pods backCommercial composting only, not home compostable; Tayst sell a $20 Down To Earth return kit for posting used pods back
Roast LevelDarkDark
Roaster NamedTaystTayst
Origin structureBlendBlend
Subscription Available✓✓
Tasting NotesRich and full-bodied with a smoky cocoa finishDeep and dark, full-bodied, smooth finish
Third-party compatible✓✓

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods vs Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods: common questions

Which is better, Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods or Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods?

Both score 6.9 out of 10 on the specifications their makers publish, so neither is ahead overall. Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods leads on nothing scored.

Is Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods or Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods cheaper?

Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods starts at $41.65, and Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods at $41.65. Per pod they work out at $1.04/pod and $1.04/pod.

Who is Tayst Bold & Brazen Coffee Pods for?

A dark, cocoa-heavy K-Cup for somebody who wants the pod compostable and does not want it weak

Who is Tayst Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods for?

Chemical-free Swiss Water decaf in a pod that composts

Keep comparing