Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic vs Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate

The verdict

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic is narrowly ahead, 8.2 to Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate's 7.8. It leads on process & cup quality and convenience & format.

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic costs $13.6 less.

Who each one suits

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic

people who want specialty coffee from a direct trade roaster

Scores higher on process & cup quality, convenience & format, packaging & shelf life.

Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate

Iced coffee and milk drinks without equipment, cheaper per cup than specialty instant

Scores higher on sourcing transparency.

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightIntelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat ClassicJot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate
Process & Cup Quality30%10.09.0
Convenience & Format20%7.56.5
Sourcing Transparency18%2.77.7
Packaging & Shelf Life16%10.06.7

What each one costs

Price$13.00$26.60
Cost per cup
The figure that decides what the choice costs over a year, not on the day.
$2.60/cup$1.90/cup

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat ClassicJot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate
Price$13.00$26.60
Best forpeople who want specialty coffee from a direct trade roasterIced coffee and milk drinks without equipment, cheaper per cup than specialty instant
What sets it apartFreeze-dried rather than spray-dried, and the only instant here profiled as an espresso—
CertificationsNone claimed by the makerNone published
Coffee Grams per Bag4.5—
Direct Trade✕—
Dose per Serving—1 tablespoon
Format—Liquid concentrate
Hot or Cold—Both, and it mixes into cold milk without clumping
Origin—Peru, Colombia, Honduras
Packaging TypeSachetGlass bottle, 6.8oz
PreparationJust add water or milk, per the box—
Price per Serving2.60 USD1.90 USD
Process MethodFreeze-driedLiquid ultra-concentrate (20x), brewed then concentrated
Resealable✕—
Roast Level—Medium
Roaster CountryUnited States—
Roaster Country CodeUS—
Roaster NamedIntelligentsia CoffeeJot
Servings per Pack514
Ships toUS, worldwide—
Ships to NoteShips internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.—
Storage—Refrigerate after opening
Subscription Available✓✓
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, raw sugar and marshmallowSmooth and chocolatey; built to work black or under milk
Tasting Notes NoteIntelligentsia's own words, printed on the box.—

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic
  • +Freeze dried from Intelligentsia's Black Cat espresso blend, with published notes of dark chocolate, raw sugar and marshmallow
  • +Single-serve sachets with a subscription available
  • −$2.60 a serving, dearer per cup than any other instant here
  • −Five servings a pack
  • −Not resealable, and Intelligentsia claims no certifications and no direct trade for it
Full Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic review →
Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate
  • +$1.90 a cup, against $2.60 for Intelligentsia's specialty instant
  • +Mixes into cold milk without clumping, which instant does not, iced coffee in seconds
  • +One tablespoon, no equipment, and the strength is yours to set
  • +Origins named: Peruvian, with Colombian and Honduran
  • −Refrigerated once opened, where a jar of instant keeps in a cupboard for a year
  • −Fourteen cups a bottle, so a light drinker buys a fortnight at a time
  • −A glass bottle does not travel the way a sachet does
  • −Far more expensive than supermarket instant, which is cents a cup
Full Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate review →

Every specification, side by side

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat ClassicJot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate
Price
Price$13.00$26.60
Who it suits
Best forpeople who want specialty coffee from a direct trade roasterIced coffee and milk drinks without equipment, cheaper per cup than specialty instant
What sets it apartFreeze-dried rather than spray-dried, and the only instant here profiled as an espresso—
Specifications
CertificationsNone claimed by the makerNone published
Coffee Grams per Bag4.5—
Decaf in the range✕✕
Direct Trade✕—
Dose per Serving—1 tablespoon
FlavouredNot flavouredNot flavoured
Format—Liquid concentrate
Hot or Cold—Both, and it mixes into cold milk without clumping
Origin—Peru, Colombia, Honduras
Packaging TypeSachetGlass bottle, 6.8oz
PreparationJust add water or milk, per the box—
Price per Serving2.60 USD1.90 USD
Process MethodFreeze-driedLiquid ultra-concentrate (20x), brewed then concentrated
Resealable✕—
Roast Level—Medium
Roaster CountryUnited States—
Roaster Country CodeUS—
Roaster NamedIntelligentsia CoffeeJot
Servings per Pack514
Ships toUS, worldwide—
Ships to NoteShips internationally as well as within the US. The roaster does not publish a country list, and import duties fall to the buyer.—
Origin structureBlendBlend
Storage—Refrigerate after opening
Subscription Available✓✓
Tasting NotesDark chocolate, raw sugar and marshmallowSmooth and chocolatey; built to work black or under milk
Tasting Notes NoteIntelligentsia's own words, printed on the box.—

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic vs Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate: common questions

Which is better, Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic or Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate?

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic scores 8.2 against 7.8, both computed from published specifications rather than opinion. Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate is still ahead on sourcing transparency.

Is Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic or Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate cheaper?

Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic starts at $13.00, and Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate at $26.60. Per cup they work out at $2.60/cup and $1.90/cup.

Who is Intelligentsia Instant Espresso Black Cat Classic for?

people who want specialty coffee from a direct trade roaster

Who is Jot Original Ultra Coffee Concentrate for?

Iced coffee and milk drinks without equipment, cheaper per cup than specialty instant

Keep comparing