Origin Coffee Subscription vs Peet's Coffee Subscription

The verdict

Origin Coffee Subscription is the better buy on our scoring, 8.4 to Peet's Coffee Subscription's 7.8. It leads on cancelling, skipping & getting out and freshness & roast dates.

Who each one suits

Origin Coffee Subscription

British buyers who want next-day despatch and a letterbox-sized bag

Scores higher on cancelling, skipping & getting out, freshness & roast dates, what actually arrives.

Peet's Coffee Subscription

The cheapest coffee per kilo of any subscription here, priced honestly by the pound

Scores higher on cost per bag, and per kilo, choice & personalisation.

How they score, criterion by criterion

Both are scored the same way against the rest of their category, from what their makers publish. The weight is how much each criterion moves the total. How the score works

CriterionWeightOrigin Coffee SubscriptionPeet's Coffee Subscription
Cancelling, Skipping & Getting Out24%10.09.1
Cost Per Bag, and Per Kilo22%6.58.4
Freshness & Roast Dates16%10.05.0
Choice & Personalisation16%6.36.6
What Actually Arrives12%10.07.9
Delivery & Straight Answers10%10.08.0

What each one costs

Price$16Not publicly stated

Where they differ

Every specification the two makers publish differently. Everything they match on is in the full table below.

Origin Coffee SubscriptionPeet's Coffee Subscription
Price$16—
Best forBritish buyers who want next-day despatch and a letterbox-sized bagThe cheapest coffee per kilo of any subscription here, priced honestly by the pound
Bag Price Usd Converted17.00—
Bag Size250 g454 g
Cancel Online✓✓
CertificationsB Corp—
Cost per Bag—19.95 USD
Days Roast to Despatch1—
Decaf in the range—✓
First Box Discount✓✓
Frequency OptionsEvery 1, 2, 3 or 4 weeksYes, how much and how often are both chosen at signup
Gift Option✓✓
Grind OptionsWhole beans, ground for filter, or ground for AeroPressgrind is chosen at signup
Pause Subscription✓—
Price Is Converted✓—
Price per kg—43.98 USD
Price Source CurrencyGBP—
Pricing Published Upfront✓✓
Quiz or Matching✓—
Roast Choice—Eight curated series - Small Batch, Dark Roast, Seasonal Essentials, Medium Roast, Signature Blend, Cold Brew, Single Origin and Decaf - or build your own
Roasted to Order✓—
Roaster CountryUnited KingdomUnited States
Roasters Named✓✓
Shipping Included✓✓
Ships toUK, EU, US, worldwide—
Single Origin Available✓✓
Skip Delivery✓✓
Specialty Grade✓—
Subscription URLhttps://www.origincoffee.co.uk/pages/coffee-subscriptionshttps://www.peets.com/pages/subscriptions

Pros and cons

From each full review, written from the same published facts as the scores above.

Origin Coffee Subscription
  • +Next-day despatch on daily fresh roasts, which is the tightest published roast-to-post window in this batch.
  • +Free delivery on every subscription order, with no bundle or minimum to earn it.
  • +The bag is sized to fit through a letterbox, so a delivery does not need somebody at home.
  • +A certified B Corp, with the sourcing commitments that certification requires, rather than a self-declared claim.
  • +Ships to the UK, EU, US and worldwide, which is the widest reach in this batch.
  • −Pausing, skipping and cancelling are done through their iOS and Android app, and no web equivalent is stated.
  • −Priced in pounds. Our dollar figure is a converted estimate and is deliberately not scored, so the value criterion sits at the midpoint.
  • −One roaster only, so there is no discovery of other roasters.
  • −The free-delivery threshold is advertised at both £25 and £35 in different places on the site, which needs clarifying at the basket.
  • −No money-back guarantee is stated.
Full Origin Coffee Subscription review →
Peet's Coffee Subscription
  • +$43.98 a kilo on the Signature Blend Series, which is the cheapest coffee per kilo in this comparison by a wide margin.
  • +Priced by the pound on the page, so the per-kilo figure is published rather than derived from an assumed bag size.
  • +Free shipping on every subscription, with no bundle or spend threshold.
  • +Eight curated series including single origin, cold brew and a dedicated decaf series, or build your own from individual coffees.
  • +Reschedule or cancel at any time, and grind, quantity and frequency are all chosen at signup.
  • −No roasted-to-order claim is made, unlike Trade, Misto, Intelligentsia and Origin.
  • −No specialty-grade claim on the subscriptions page, and no direct trade or certification statement.
  • −One roaster, so there is no discovery beyond Peet's own range.
  • −No money-back guarantee is stated.
  • −The 30% new-subscriber discount makes the first orders much cheaper than the ongoing price, which is the number to plan around.
Full Peet's Coffee Subscription review →

Every specification, side by side

Origin Coffee SubscriptionPeet's Coffee Subscription
Price
Price$16—
Who it suits
Best forBritish buyers who want next-day despatch and a letterbox-sized bagThe cheapest coffee per kilo of any subscription here, priced honestly by the pound
Specifications
Bag Price Usd Converted17.00—
Bag Size250 g454 g
Cancel Online✓✓
CertificationsB Corp—
Cost per Bag—19.95 USD
Days Roast to Despatch1—
Decaf in the range—✓
First Box Discount✓✓
Frequency OptionsEvery 1, 2, 3 or 4 weeksYes, how much and how often are both chosen at signup
Gift Option✓✓
Grind OptionsWhole beans, ground for filter, or ground for AeroPressgrind is chosen at signup
Min Commitment Deliveries11
Pause Subscription✓—
Price Is Converted✓—
Price per kg—43.98 USD
Price Source CurrencyGBP—
Pricing Published Upfront✓✓
Quiz or Matching✓—
Roast Choice—Eight curated series - Small Batch, Dark Roast, Seasonal Essentials, Medium Roast, Signature Blend, Cold Brew, Single Origin and Decaf - or build your own
Roasted to Order✓—
Roaster CountryUnited KingdomUnited States
Roasters11
Roasters Named✓✓
Shipping Included✓✓
Ships toUK, EU, US, worldwide—
Single Origin Available✓✓
Skip Delivery✓✓
Specialty Grade✓—
Subscription TypeRoaster's ownRoaster's own
Subscription URLhttps://www.origincoffee.co.uk/pages/coffee-subscriptionshttps://www.peets.com/pages/subscriptions

Origin Coffee Subscription vs Peet's Coffee Subscription: common questions

Which is better, Origin Coffee Subscription or Peet's Coffee Subscription?

Origin Coffee Subscription scores 8.4 against 7.8, both computed from published specifications rather than opinion. Peet's Coffee Subscription is still ahead on cost per bag, and per kilo.

Is Origin Coffee Subscription or Peet's Coffee Subscription cheaper?

Origin Coffee Subscription starts at $16, and Peet's Coffee Subscription at Not publicly stated.

Who is Origin Coffee Subscription for?

British buyers who want next-day despatch and a letterbox-sized bag

Who is Peet's Coffee Subscription for?

The cheapest coffee per kilo of any subscription here, priced honestly by the pound

Keep comparing