Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon Coffee Bean Review

An organic Indonesian coffee that is sweet and chocolatey rather than earthy

Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon is a USDA Organic, medium roast single origin coffee from the Kintamani Highlands of Bali, roasted to order in central Pennsylvania and sold in 12 oz, 2 lb and 5 lb bags.

Spec-led review. Built from the manufacturer’s published specification and price rather than hands-on testing. Figures we could not find stated are left blank instead of estimated. Updated when we get one in.

Where you can buy itUS confirmed
Our rating
8.7/ 10
Excellent
4 of 6 scored, out of 35.7 points · 64.3 not judgeable from specs

How we rate coffee beans : what each criterion measures, and what we cannot.

Taste & Flavour Quality—
28 pts · not scored from specs
why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 28 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Freshness & Roast Date Transparency (roast date printed only)10.0 / 10
worth 8 of 35.7 · 12 unpublished · well evidenced
how we got 10.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Roast date printedYes4.0 / 4.0
Not best-before onlynot applicable—
Ships after roastnot applicable—
One-way valvenot applicable—

The rows that apply here are worth 4.0 between them and this one took 4.0, which is 10.0 out of 10. That 0 to 10 result is what the criterion's 8 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

Sourcing Transparency & Ethics (altitude and varietals not published)6.4 / 10
worth 11.2 of 35.7 · 4.8 unpublished · well evidenced
how we got 6.4

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Origin typeSingle origin1.5 / 1.5
Origin namedIndonesia1.5 / 1.5
Altitude publishednot applicable—
Varietals publishednot applicable—
CertificationsUSDA Organic, OU Kosher1.5 / 1.5
Direct tradeNo0.0 / 1.5
Farm or co-op namedNo0.0 / 1.0

The rows that apply here are worth 7.0 between them and this one took 4.5, which is 6.4 out of 10. That 0 to 10 result is what the criterion's 11.2 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

Value Per Kilo10.0 / 10
worth 14 of 35.7 · well evidenced
how we got 10.0
Roast Consistency—
12 pts · not scored from specs
why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 12 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Packaging & Freshness Retention (bag size only)8.0 / 10
worth 2.5 of 35.7 · 7.5 unpublished · well evidenced
how we got 8.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Packagingnot applicable—
One-way valvenot applicable—
Bag size['340 g (12 oz)', '907 g (2 lb)', '2.27 kg (5 lb)']2.0 / 2.5

The rows that apply here are worth 2.5 between them and this one took 2.0, which is 8.0 out of 10. That 0 to 10 result is what the criterion's 2.5 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

How Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon tastes

The roaster’s own notes, in the order they list them. Roasters lead with what they want tasted first, so the bars follow that order rather than any score of ours.

Every way to buy it

FormatSizePricePer kiloPer cup
Whole bean or ground340 g (12 oz)$17.99$52.88$0.79
Whole bean or ground907 g (2 lb)$36.99$40.77$0.61
Whole bean or ground2.27 kg (5 lb)$69.99$30.86best$0.46
How these prices are worked out
  • Prices are the roaster’s own, and they change.
  • Per cup for a bag is worked out at 15 g of coffee a cup, which is a stated convention rather than a measurement. Pods are exact, because the count is printed on the box.
The verdict

Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon is a USDA Organic, wet-hulled single origin from the Kintamani Highlands of Bali, grown at 1,300 to 1,700 m. It is roasted medium and labelled bold bodied, with notes of dark chocolate, vanilla bean and anise. It costs $17.99 for 12 oz or $69.99 for 5 lb, about $30.86 a kilo, with the roast date on the bag.

Pros

  • USDA Organic, certified by PA Certified Organic.
  • Altitude, region, process and harvest all published.
  • Roasted to order, with the roast date on the bag.
  • About $30.86 a kilo in the 5 lb bag.

Cons

  • Farms not named.
  • $3 a bag dearer than Fresh Roasted's non-organic origins.
  • Heavy and low in acidity, not for lovers of bright coffee.
From $17.99

What is Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon?

An Indonesian coffee that trades the earth for chocolate, and one of Fresh Roasted's best sellers.

Fresh Roasted call this one of their all-time best sellers and say it is not a typical earthy Indonesian coffee: the earthy notes are subtle, and what comes forward is syrupy dark chocolate, a creamy mouthfeel and a spiced finish. The bag reads medium roast and bold bodied, with notes of dark chocolate, vanilla bean and anise, and carries the USDA Organic seal, certified by PA Certified Organic. It is also OU Kosher.

It is sold whole bean or ground in 12 oz, 2 lb and 5 lb bags, and it is one of the single origins on the Fresh Roasted Coffee roaster page.

Where it comes from

For once, a bag that tells you the altitude and the harvest.

Fresh Roasted publish the details: the Kintamani Highlands of Bali, 4,265 to 5,577 feet, which is about 1,300 to 1,700 m, wet hulled, harvested from May to July and exported from August to October. Their history of the coffee is that after a devastating volcanic eruption in 1963, the Balinese government handed out coffee seed stock to farmers and encouraged coffee growing across the island. They say Bali now has over 7,000 hectares of organic coffee land, where pesticides and chemicals are not allowed on the crops.

Roasted to order, and dated on the bag

The strongest thing Fresh Roasted publishes is not a tasting note. It is when the coffee was roasted.

Fresh Roasted Coffee roasts each order after it is placed, on Loring Smart Roasters at its base in central Pennsylvania, then packs and nitrogen flushes the bag straight away. Its shipping policy says coffee leaves one to two days after roasting, and orders placed after noon on a Thursday are roasted on Sunday night and shipped on Monday.

The roast date is printed on a white sticker on the bottom of every bag. It is written as a Julian day, the number of the day in the year, so day 272 is the 29th of September. It takes a second to decode, and the roaster's FAQ has the chart, but it means you can see exactly how old the coffee is, which most supermarket bags will not tell you. A best before date on a supermarket bag says when the seller stops standing behind it, not when it was roasted.

What wet hulling does

The same process as Sumatra, and a sweeter result.

Wet hulling, called giling basah in Indonesia, is the reason Indonesian coffees taste the way they do. The coffee is pulped and briefly fermented, then the parchment is stripped off while the beans are still wet, instead of after drying as in most of the world. The beans dry fast and exposed, turn a dark green, and roast into a cup with heavy body, low acidity and the earthy, cedar and spice notes that people either love or avoid. It is a practical answer to a humid climate and small farms, and it is the single biggest thing to know about a coffee from Sumatra or Bali.

Bali Blue Moon is the gentler end of that style. Where the Fresh Roasted Sumatra Mandheling label reads dark chocolate, cedar and heavy, this one reads dark chocolate, vanilla bean and anise.

Price, and what a cup costs

A small premium for organic, still under a dollar a cup.

BagPricePer kiloPer cup (15 g)
340 g (12 oz)$17.99$52.88$0.79
907 g (2 lb)$36.99$40.77$0.61
2.27 kg (5 lb)$69.99$30.86$0.46

Shipping is a flat $7.95 on orders under $50 and free above $50 once discounts are taken off, so two 2 lb bags or three 12 oz bags usually clear the threshold.

New to Fresh Roasted Coffee? Our link applies the code COFFEEGURU, which takes 20% off a first order of coffee or tea. It is for new customers only and does not apply to subscriptions.

Fresh Roasted also sell it as organic single-serve pods for K-Cup brewers, as Nespresso Original compatible espresso capsules, and green for home roasting.

Bali Blue Moon vs other organic Indonesians

Sweeter than a Sumatra, and cheaper than the certified Sumatra we review.

The Cooper's Cask Sumatra Dark Roast is also organic, roasted darker, at $18.95 for 12 oz and $35.25 a kilo in 5 lb, with no roast date. Bali Blue Moon is a dollar cheaper per bag, publishes its altitude and harvest, and dates the bag. If you want an organic decaf in the same family, Fresh Roasted's Organic Sumatra Water-Processed Decaf is the one.

How to brew it

Body first: French press, drip, or espresso with milk.

The syrupy body and low acidity make it an easy coffee to like in a French press or a drip machine at 1:16, and it takes milk well. As espresso it gives a sweet, heavy shot with chocolate to the front. Grind it fresh: the vanilla and anise notes are the first thing to fade in a bag of ground coffee. Our guide to storing coffee beans covers keeping a 5 lb bag fresh.

Is it worth it?

Yes, and it is the most fully documented coffee in this range.

Organic, dated, with its altitude and harvest published, at under 80 cents a cup in the small bag: there is very little to argue with. The only gap is the names of the farms.

Who should buy it (and who should not)

Buy it if

  • You want an organic coffee with low acidity and a sweet, heavy body.
  • You like dark chocolate and spice more than fruit.
  • You want the altitude and harvest on the page, and a date on the bag.

Skip it if

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bali Blue Moon organic?

Yes. The bag carries the USDA Organic seal, certified by PA Certified Organic.

What does it taste like?

The label lists dark chocolate, vanilla bean and anise; Fresh Roasted describe a syrupy, creamy cup with a spiced finish.

Where is it grown?

The Kintamani Highlands of Bali, at 4,265 to 5,577 feet, about 1,300 to 1,700 m.

Is it Rainforest Alliance certified?

Fresh Roasted's page and bag claim USDA Organic and OU Kosher, not Rainforest Alliance, so we list those two.

Is it good for espresso?

Yes: its heavy body and low acidity make a sweet espresso, especially with milk.

Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon appears in

Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon is featured in

More on coffee beans

Background reading that puts this review in context.

Alternatives to Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon

See all Fresh Roasted Coffee Organic Bali Blue Moon alternatives →

Other Coffee Beans options we've reviewed.