Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power Dark Roast Coffee Bean Review

The heaviest bodied of the range, for espresso and for milk

Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power is a Certified Organic, Fairtrade and Kosher dark roast whole bean blend with a heavy body, sweet tobacco and a black licorice finish, in 283g bags.

Spec-led review. Built from the manufacturer’s published specification and price rather than hands-on testing. Figures we could not find stated are left blank instead of estimated. Updated when we get one in.

Where you can buy itUS confirmed

Confirmed on Amazon US, which is where this link points. Availability in other Amazon stores has not been checked, and a regional store may substitute a different product.

Our rating
5.6/ 10
Decent
4 of 6 scored, out of 35.7 points · 64.3 not judgeable from specs

How we rate coffee beans — what each criterion measures, and what we cannot.

Taste & Flavour Quality
28 pts · not scored from specs
why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 28 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Freshness & Roast Date Transparency (roast date printed only)5.0 / 10
worth 8 of 35.7 · 12 unpublished · thinly evidenced
how we got 5.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 0% published.
Roast date printednot in our data2.0 / 4.0
Not best-before onlynot applicable
Ships after roastnot applicable
One-way valvenot applicable

The rows that apply here are worth 4.0 between them and this one took 2.0, which is 5.0 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 8 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

The 4.0 points we could not find a figure for are scored at the middle of the scale rather than as a zero, which awards 2.0 of them: the greyed figures above. We will not guess a specification and we will not mark the product down for our own missing research.

Sourcing Transparency & Ethics (altitude and varietals not published)6.4 / 10
worth 11.2 of 35.7 · 4.8 unpublished · thinly evidenced
how we got 6.4

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 43% published.
Origin typeBlend1.0 / 1.5
Origin namednot in our data0.75 / 1.5
Altitude publishednot applicable
Varietals publishednot applicable
CertificationsFairtrade, Organic, Kosher1.5 / 1.5
Direct tradenot in our data0.75 / 1.5
Farm or co-op namednot in our data0.5 / 1.0

The rows that apply here are worth 7.0 between them and this one took 4.5, which is 6.4 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 11.2 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

The 4.0 points we could not find a figure for are scored at the middle of the scale rather than as a zero, which awards 2.0 of them: the greyed figures above. We will not guess a specification and we will not mark the product down for our own missing research.

Value Per Kilo (no price published)5.0 / 10
worth 14 of 35.7 · not evidenced
how we got 5.0
Roast Consistency
12 pts · not scored from specs
why there is no number here

what this measures, and what we cannot

needs a judgement that no published spec stands in for. Its 12 points are taken out of the total rather than scored as a zero, so the overall rating is out of what we could check. This neither helps nor hurts the product.

Packaging & Freshness Retention (bag size only)8.0 / 10
worth 2.5 of 35.7 · 7.5 unpublished · well evidenced
how we got 8.0

what this measures, and what we cannot

What it was scored onScored from the specs the maker publishes. 100% published.
Packagingnot applicable
One-way valvenot applicable
Bag size['283 g (10 oz)']2.0 / 2.5

The rows that apply here are worth 2.5 between them and this one took 2.0, which is 8.0 out of 10. That 0–10 result is what the criterion's 2.5 of 35.7 points are then scaled by.

How Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power Dark Roast tastes

The roaster’s own notes, in the order they list them. Roasters lead with what they want tasted first, so the bars follow that order rather than any score of ours.

  • Earthy
The verdict

Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power is a Certified Organic, Fairtrade and Kosher dark roast whole bean blend with a heavy body, sweet tobacco and a black licorice finish, in 283g bags.

Pros

  • Certified Organic, Fairtrade and Kosher, which is three certifications where most bags here carry one or none
  • Green coffee only: Kicking Horse states no preservatives, additives, fillers or flavourings
  • Roasted in the Canadian Rockies in a facility the maker says makes only coffee
  • Detailed published notes: heavy body, sweet tobacco, earthy, with a black licorice finish

Cons

  • 283g, among the smallest bags in this category
  • No origin countries are published, only that it is a blend
  • No price is published for it here

What is 454 Horse Power?

The most intense coffee Kicking Horse publishes, and it does not hide it.

Kicking Horse publishes a heavy body with sweet tobacco, earthy character and a black licorice finish, an aroma of cacao nibs, peat and hints of nutmeg, a dark roast described as velvety, earthy and spirited, Certified Organic, Fairtrade and Kosher status, and green coffee as the only ingredient. The bag is 10oz.

Peat and tobacco are unusual notes to publish

They are savoury descriptors, and most roasters avoid them.

Coffee marketing runs on chocolate, caramel and nuts, because those are flavours nobody dislikes. Tobacco and peat are the vocabulary of whisky and cigars: dry, smoky, vegetal and distinctly adult.

Publishing them is a filter. It tells the buyer who this coffee is not for, which is more useful than another bag promising smooth chocolate. If those words appeal, this is the coffee. If they do not, Grizzly Claw is the sweet dark roast in the same range.

Heavy body, and what that actually means

Body is mouthfeel, not strength, and the two get confused constantly.

Body is the weight and texture of the liquid: whether it feels like skimmed milk or like cream. It comes from dissolved solids and suspended oils, and it is largely independent of how much caffeine or how much coffee flavour is present.

A heavy-bodied coffee carries through milk without vanishing, which is why this is the bag in the range best suited to a flat white or a moka pot with hot milk. It also means a French press or a metal filter suits it better than paper, since paper strips the oils that carry the body.

What it does not mean is more caffeine. Kicking Horse publishes no caffeine figure for any coffee in this range, and dose matters far more than roast for that in any case.

454 Horse Power vs Kick Ass

Both dark, and this is the one with fewer friends and more character.

Kick Ass is chocolate malt and molasses: the crowd-pleasing dark roast, and by review count much the more popular.

454 is savoury where Kick Ass is sweet, and heavier in the mouth. For a household buying one bag, Kick Ass. For somebody who finds most dark roasts samey, this is the interesting one.

Is 454 Horse Power worth it?

Worth it if the tasting notes appeal. Genuinely not if they do not.

It carries the same three certifications and the same no-additives policy as the rest of the range, at the same supermarket price. The only question is whether you want a savoury, peaty coffee, and the listing tells you honestly.

Kicking Horse publishes no origin country, farm, altitude, varietal, processing method or roast date on this bag. Nor does it publish a caffeine figure, despite the name inviting the assumption.

Who should buy it (and who should not)

Buy it for milk drinks, a press, or a palate that likes whisky vocabulary.

It suits a moka pot, a French press, an espresso machine used for milk-based drinks, and anybody bored of chocolate-and-caramel dark roasts.

Do not buy it as a first bag from this roaster, which is Kick Ass's job. Do not buy it for a paper filter, which strips the body that is the point. And do not buy it expecting more caffeine, because none is published.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does 454 Horse Power have more caffeine?

No figure is published. The name refers to the blend, not a measured caffeine content, and dose matters more than roast anyway.

What does it taste like?

Heavy body, sweet tobacco, earthy, with a black licorice finish, and an aroma of cacao nibs, peat and nutmeg.

How is it different from Kick Ass?

Savoury rather than sweet, and heavier in the mouth. Kick Ass leads on chocolate malt and molasses.

Is it certified?

Yes, Certified Organic, Fairtrade and Kosher.

What brewer suits it?

A metal filter or a press keeps the oils that carry its body. Paper strips them.

Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power Dark Roast appears in

More on coffee beans

Background reading that puts this review in context.

Alternatives to Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power Dark Roast

See all Kicking Horse 454 Horse Power Dark Roast alternatives →

Other Coffee Beans options we've reviewed.